Elektrine lite

← Feed

@violetmadder@kolektiva.social

Post #984051

2026-04-07 18:00 UTC

I just went to a workshop for job seekers who need special help. The moment I asked about resumes: "Oh, ChatGPT will fix all of that for you!" They were downright gushing about it. I know in an abstract way, the average reading level is something around 5th grade, but I'm not directly exposed to it much. A few attendees were really struggling with the booklets we'd been handed. This "AI" technology was being hyped to them like a godsend. When writing a cover letter feels something like being asked to encode ritual alien poetry in hieroglyphics, somebody who's never been able to produce a properly structured paragraph before must feel tantalizingly liberated. A whole new door opens! As I sat watching "AI" treated as a miracle cure, the fact I was biting back the bile must have shown on my face past my mask-- the person doing my paperwork remarked on the "look" I gave her (well, not her directly, I tried to aim it at the table). I told her this stuff is 'hallucinating' around 16%-48% of the time, and she blinked at me. Blankly. I didn't even try to bring up any of the weaponization, propaganda etc etc etc. She shrugged and said, "Oh, but I always review it. I know how to assess what it gives me." And for her purposes, she's probably right. Mostly. She's an expert in her role and good at what she does-- but the people she serves?? How many people out there not only aren't equipped to assess the slop's output, but haven't got the slightest CLUE it could be unreliable and even needs to be assessed in the first place? The digital oracle knows best. Computers are smart! Gah. #"AI" #AI #LLM #slop

Replies (6)

  • This place serves people who've had major mental health issues or substance abuse, been houseless or incarcerated etc. The marginalized. Many are not very educated. When the group was asked what kind of work they want, one person shrugged and said "Janitorial". The teacher winced and amended her question, "I mean what did you want to be when you grew up? What's your DREAM job?" There was a heavy silence. One person thought about it for a long, long moment and said, "...Grape picking?" "Where do you see yourself in 5 years?" "........Better pay?" "But what role in your job? What do you see yourself doing?" "...My own apartment?" This is the population the fascist techbros see not even as prey, just vermin. Pathetic suckers. Bowls of worms. Stupid. Disposable. Misery cultivated to scare other workers into line. Some of us are already so ground down we don't know how to dream anymore. It all seems so far out of reach. Some FEEL stupid, due to how they've been treated, with little awareness of the insight, wisdom, and potential they actually possess. The faces in that room were determined but tired. So very tired. I walk in to a facility like this with my smartypants vocabulary and the staff look bewildered that I'm even there and say, "Oh you'll have NO problem" but it's not fucking true, I've never been able to support myself like a functional grownup. My grades were always bad, I'm constantly late and forgetful, I couldn't finish college, I keep getting fired. I've been couch surfing for years. Most of my adult life I've been living on around $500/month. But I sure sound smart. On paper, I'm supposed to be a genius. I stand with one foot inches from an elite world, and the other foot inches from the gutter. I want to use that, and help bridge the gaps of understanding. I'm a peer support specialist. Marginalized folks are the population I'll be serving. Some will be "gifted" burnouts like me, and more will be people who don't know a lot of words over two or three syllables. I've got to be effective at connecting with people who've had very little education, and/or have developmental disabilities or a lot of damage from trauma and substances and so on, without alienating them or getting condescending. I at least have some awareness of how bad things really get, but my own life has been frankly pretty sheltered. I even look soft-- it shows on the skin, when somebody has been on the streets a long time. I'm not going to be as useful in this role, in some ways, as say that hardened guy over there with all the tattoos or my coworker who overcame a multi-decade meth addiction (I've never even tried normal smoking). I'm headed to the psychological front lines. I'm going to be hearing some of the most heartbreaking, awful stories and seeing a lot of suffering. I'm looking for people who've seen the cracks in the system, been burned by the festering evil driving it, and want to push for a real change. Some of them I might be able to help reach a way to move forward and fight. Some, we'll lose to the pits of drugs and despair. Some will die. It's a soul-destroying meat grinder out there. Where's my niche? Where can I be most useful? How well can I handle the stress? Big question marks.

    Open ##1440991

  • @Steve@social.coop 2026-04-07 18:04

    @violetmadder If you're an above-average writer, AI will pull your quality down. If you're a below-average writer, AI will pull your quality up, but in doing so, will create unrealistic expectations about you. And that's before we get to the flagrant inaccuracies.

    Open ##1440992

  • @JustinMac84@mastodon.social 2026-04-07 18:29

    @violetmadder When self-righteous social media people start blocking them because they dare to use AI and the blockers can't distinguish the symptom from the problem, they're going to be so confused.

    Open ##1441032

  • @coba@gruene.social 2026-04-08 10:16

    @violetmadder what I understood is, people have failed people for so long. Education wasn't inclusive. Work places aren't inclusive. Etc. And AI may be wrong and bad but it is there. It is a crutch. And 50% correct is better than no letter at all. It crushes my heart because with all that is behind ai. It should be banned for most use cases and only controlled in research environment.

    Open ##1441033

  • @violetmadder this is a really interesting point. The technology is offered with the caveats of personal responsibility, but also as the path the acquire the skills needed to exercise that responsibility. That’s definitely a Catch-22 and it puts some of my concerns into perspective, relating to using LLMs for learning.

    Open ##1441034

  • @JMMaok@mastodon.online 2026-04-15 14:16

    @violetmadder This is such an important post. I have taught classes like that, way before LLMs, and feel it viscerally. Add the fact that lying on an application is typically a firing offense (in the US anyway) and it's such a problem. It reminds me of a similar-but-different situation recently, on a call for a general audience involved in data management. I was called out for using the confusing acronym LLM (which, fair, I apologized). But I bet they knew the marketing term AI ...

    Open ##1441036