2022-11-21 15:58 UTC
Replies (40)
-
@llebrun@mastodon.social 2022-11-21 16:12
I also don't think it is a serious solution to tell people, especially those from vulnerable communities, to just go find a server that respects them / allows them to criticize racism, etc. People are joining Mastodon in good faith, but if they encounter these problems once, twice or more, it starts to send them the message they're not welcome here. It becomes a real brand problem and platform integrity issue.
-
@Pheneatis@mstdn.ca 2022-11-21 16:00
@llebrun@mastodon.social Yes, I heard the same thing from someone posting about racialized issues on .social who got their post moderated for no reason. I think it's really important to find a good instance (but then, you never know who will change their views).
-
@mvlasic@mstdn.ca 2022-11-21 16:07
@llebrun@mastodon.social Looks to be a big problem. You'd think they'd have a central set of rules around moderating.
-
@ingomar_gutmann@fediscience.org 2022-11-21 16:07
@llebrun@mastodon.social i suggest fediscience.org @admin@fediscience.org A great server!
-
@peleg@leftodon.social 2022-11-21 16:09
@llebrun@mastodon.social Isn't that mostly a big problem for that particular instance? Good instances, especially the big ones, should have strict and transparent moderation scheme. We should learn from such cases and improve common practices in the fediverse.
-
@jeanpaulphd@mastodon.world 2022-11-21 16:11
@llebrun@mastodon.social I’m not commenting on this situation because I don’t know the details, but it got me wondering how easy it is to move to a different part of the #fediverse? How easy is it to change servers or whatever? #noob
-
@StephanieCarvin@mastodon.online 2022-11-21 16:14
@llebrun@mastodon.social Bloody hell.
-
@jorval@chaos.social 2022-11-21 16:20
@llebrun@mastodon.social That's the heaven and hell of Open,Free and decentralized platforms like it always was. The solution to that problem is simple, find the right instance(s) for yourself (or herself in that case) i know there are lot's of journalists now hopping over to mastodon and i belive there where instances for journalists too. do we create more bubbles. yes. but that is not a technical problem, it's human.
-
@JamesLHSprague@mstdn.social 2022-11-21 16:25
@llebrun@mastodon.social @StephanieCarvin@mastodon.online Wouldn’t the solution just be to chose another instance (server)? Or does the suspension on one work across all of the servers?
-
@jonincalgary@yyc.bike 2022-11-21 16:29
@llebrun@mastodon.social I imagine there is also the risk of hostile mod takeover like happens with Reddit as well.
-
@sbz@metalhead.club 2022-11-21 16:32
@llebrun@mastodon.social this is the problem of mega instances with dubious owners. One sets up their own instance (and defederates known eejits like mastodon.online), and the problem is solved.
-
@dpfyhrie@fediscience.org 2022-11-21 16:34
@llebrun@mastodon.social I'm a noob, so take this as a partially informed opinion: A "federated" social network seems to mean that each instance is independent and will do what it wants to. I presume that there can be instances that have a bill of rights, elected governance, taxes, and etc. but many seem to be "dictatorships" run by the people who set them up. Fortunately, there seems to not be any limit to how many instances that can be built.
-
@orenbell@social.coop 2022-11-21 16:39
@llebrun@mastodon.social different servers should more adequately advertise their policies. The larger ones are just Twitter with Reddit mods. But others are democratically run (check my handle). It would be nice if servers were also transparent about who they filter/block. Everyone has their own balance for what content they want to see, and what content they believe no one should see. But as it stands, everyone is just flocking to one of the top 5 servers paying no mind to the moderation policies.
-
@calmecam@mstdn.ca 2022-11-21 16:39
@llebrun@mastodon.social But Erica is both a serious and quality journalist. This is indeed "curious", at best...
-
@chrisale@mstdn.ca 2022-11-21 16:44
@llebrun@mastodon.social this will be what makes mastodon work, or not. There needs to be one global standard, as there was (for better or worse) on the other place. It’s not to make it like the other place, it’s to ensure that everyone knows that this place will be a place that is safe and where people can actually express themselves as long as it’s not against a minority/persecuted people.
-
@ole@mstdn.ca 2022-11-21 16:44
@llebrun@mastodon.social I'm interested in what would be a solve for this. At a minimum a clear way to see what's blocked and why?
-
@Deglassco@mastodon.social 2022-11-21 16:45
@llebrun@mastodon.social Like always, this is going to be a real struggle for black folks.
-
@django@social.coop 2022-11-21 16:57
@llebrun@mastodon.social this is outrageous, yet no it surprising. Gargron recently admitted that he did most moderation himself, now it seems he has hired some AI bots, or other such automatons (clueless wypipo) to do it. This is a pattern, that goes beyond instance moderation as well!
-
@daphne@fosstodon.org 2022-11-21 17:00
@llebrun@mastodon.social people need to be guided/helped to pick better servers to join. There is no overlord who can fix this for the entire fediverse. I notice you're on one that suspended someone for no good reason just the other day. What server was she on?
-
@4xsample@mastodon.social 2022-11-21 17:12
@llebrun@mastodon.social This is quite easy to prevent. You can set an own instance and you can open it for a group. For example, you can have a journalist instance where you only accept the register if the user is a journalist where they can publish whatever is needed. Obviously every admin can defederate any instance but this only afects the users of the instance but the information is still there.
-
@chema@social.sanfranciscan.org 2022-11-21 17:19
@llebrun@mastodon.social As someone who's been involved in a couple of controversies here and there in SF, the desire to not be dependent on churlish and politically immature moderators and admins is certainly one reason why I started my own personal instance.
-
@skydog@sfba.social 2022-11-21 17:20
@llebrun@mastodon.social The 'damage' is limited to the specific instance, is it not? And the user is free to re-subscribe, in some other instance? How does that in any way compare to the entire structure being owned an individual, who can crash everything? Granted, there will be the tendency to silo, but segregation theory explains that phenomenon.
-
@KeywordSmart@toot.community 2022-11-21 17:22
@llebrun@mastodon.social yep. Not impressed.
-
@kril@meow.social 2022-11-21 17:23
@llebrun@mastodon.social my absolute biggest gripe with mastodon, hands down
-
@stormlight@ioc.exchange 2022-11-21 17:24
@llebrun@mastodon.social this literally happened to me on mstdn.social or whatever it was
-
@tarmoamer@mstdn.party 2022-11-21 17:38
@llebrun@mastodon.social I've seen it happen on a number of sites - perfectly good, reasonable people get appointed as moderators or administrators (resp. wardens) and before you know it, there's a dictatorship brewing. The Stanford Prison Experiment has not lost its relevance. Our lizard brain never sleeps, biding its time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment
-
@theashtonstarr@mastodon.social 2022-11-21 17:42
@llebrun@mastodon.social I sent in a report to Mastodon.Online for the account. I thought it was an impersonator. 🤦
-
@Computeforloot@twit.social 2022-11-21 17:41
@llebrun@mastodon.social wow, that’s not good
-
@laurekatrine@mstdn.social 2022-11-21 17:41
@llebrun@mastodon.social this is where there is a list of the servers - I don’t know the ins and outs of what has been going on in this instance [no pun intended] but a week ago joiners were sometimes as low as 66 per hour. Now it’s 11,000 per hour. Some of the admins have expanded their instances - out of their own money - to try and accommodate people. They don’t have Elon’s deep pockets either… I expect many are simply exhausted. https://mastodon.fediverse.observer/list
-
@canpolat@hachyderm.io 2022-11-21 17:47
@llebrun@mastodon.social Is it possible to transfer an account in such cases, or do they lose everything in their accound?
-
@chriscleaner@masto.ai 2022-11-21 17:53
@llebrun@mastodon.social so what do you propose?
-
@disisdkat@mstdn.party 2022-11-21 17:55
@llebrun@mastodon.social Then I see the problem as finding the right server. It seems that what is needed is more servers.
-
@VelvetAlex@mstdn.party 2022-11-21 18:00
@llebrun@mastodon.social I left Reddit because sensitive incels had too much arbitrary power. The power they lack in real life.
-
@guy_ivester@mastodon.world 2022-11-21 18:03
@llebrun@mastodon.social It would be good to help people choose a server that doesn’t have issues. Also if this happens can we just switch servers and start over?
-
@bwithrow@journa.host 2022-11-21 18:16
@llebrun@mastodon.social I've wondered about whether this sort of thing would be a problem, with some treating it like a little fiefdom.
-
@hubick@mstdn.ca 2022-11-21 18:29
@llebrun@mastodon.social The whole benefit to Mastodon is that you can choose a community which upholds moderation standards which reflect your personal values on speech and the level of freedom vs decorum, and that there isn't a single global standard, and that you can migrate elsewhere, keeping all your relationships, should you come to disagree with the balance in your community. You're complaining about the very thing which makes this place great!
-
@pbeens@mstdn.ca 2022-11-21 18:31
@llebrun@mastodon.social I just had an interesting conversation about this with the moderators and admin on the server I'm on. They are pledging to be open and honest about their moderation policy, which I'm glad about. Read the convo here: https://mstdn.ca/@pbeens/109383062812573820
-
@nev@bananachips.club 2022-11-21 18:28
@llebrun@mastodon.social cc @chad@mstdn.ca Might want to extend an invite?
-
@denvit@mastodon.social 2022-11-21 18:37
@llebrun@mastodon.social https://about.opendolphin.social/ might be the answer
-
@risto@mastodon.world 2022-11-21 18:44
@llebrun@mastodon.social I’m curious about how this operates. As I understand it, each server belongs to “someone” as opposed to Mastodon overall. Doesn’t this mean that those server owners have their own moderation policies/personnel?