2022-11-21 16:12 UTC
Replies (12)
-
@llebrun@mastodon.social 2022-11-21 16:24
There are a lot of people with good intentions putting work and time into building this platform who are probably frazzled and burnt out by how quickly its growing (first among them, Mastodon's founder @Gargron@mastodon.social no doubt). That said, I think it needs to continually ask itself if its structure and rules are advancing its mission and values or getting in the way of them? TBH, this kind of stuff seems at odds with what I like about Mastodon.
-
@goddessvault@mstdn.ca 2022-11-21 16:15
@llebrun@mastodon.social Mastodon has rules against discrimination. The owners of those servers cannot always see them. It is up to us to flag these #Horrible actors and help kick them out.
-
@caffeneko@indieweb.social 2022-11-21 16:23
@llebrun@mastodon.social There needs to be more visibility - so that ppl can make an easier choice in selecting servers. Like a yelp rating for servers in terms of moderation and stability etc.
-
@mackensen@higheredweb.social 2022-11-21 16:31
@llebrun@mastodon.social Why not, though? That's the entire point of a decentralized architecture. One of the benefits of migrating away from Twitter is that a single moderation culture (Twitter's) doesn't speak for the entire platform.
-
@chrisale@mstdn.ca 2022-11-21 16:46
@llebrun@mastodon.social absolutely. And frankly it’s up to us white, cis, men like you and me Luke to keep saying this over and over and making it true.
-
@sikkdays@ourempty.pub 2022-11-21 17:10
@llebrun@mastodon.social Have you looked at the history of Mastodon? One of the first real large migrations was many, many LGBTQIA2+ individuals. https://blog.awkwardhuman.com/mastodon-a-social-network-for-all-humans-9c85bbfa114f In fact, thereafter this group of people reacted defensively when Wil Wheaton joined because he had previously made some trans-phobic comments. It seems like vulnerable communities have done well here so far. Was Erica censored? Was Erica looking for a 'juicy story?' I don't know. However, I am happy to have human moderators vs. algorithms
-
@dc995@ioc.exchange 2022-11-21 17:28
@llebrun@mastodon.social Content moderation is tough and this is a benefit and a curse of this platform. The mass absorption from a central curated experience to a federated server one is going to be a challenge. If you look at email, we got spam and if you look at nntp you had trolls that created server bombs. Someone cheered at Frank Zappa's death and the flames were taking down servers. God mode on muds where people would get bounced or toyed with and everyone got god mode at lvl 99. Feels old school.
-
@rabbitupnorth@mstdn.ca 2022-11-21 18:57
@llebrun@mastodon.social I hope and expect that my server respects me andy right to my views, so long as I respect others.
-
@alan@mindly.social 2022-11-21 20:10
@llebrun@mastodon.social One hopes it will settle down and that more resources show up that make it easier to pick a welcoming instance first time. A lot of privileged folks are not too comfortable with having their privilege pointed out to them, in no small part because privilege is transparent to the privileged.
-
@jcct@mastodon.online 2022-11-21 20:17
@llebrun@mastodon.social @lashman@mastodon.social Mastodon is not a “Brand”. It takes a little more work to find your place in it, but the rewards are worth it. Trying to force it into a brand model is antithetical to its purpose
-
@KenazFilan@mastodon.social 2022-11-22 01:39
@llebrun@mastodon.social Perhaps the best solution, given the decentralization of the Fediverse, would be to create directories of servers that are welcoming to people from vulnerable communities. That should help ensure they find a welcoming environment quickly. There's no Elon Musk in charge of the Fediverse to enforce Fediverse-wide terms of service. You can't shut down trolls fediverse-wide, you can only block them from your instance. Usenet had similar problems and solved them with killfiles.
-
@hypolite@friendica.mrpetovan.com 2022-11-22 02:29
@llebrun@mastodon.social If you don't think finding the suitable server for you, one of the core principles of a decentralized network, is a "serious solution", then I would advise you to stop reporting on Mastodon and the Fediverse at large, because nothing you will say will hold any water except for people like you who wrongly believe Mastodon is a brand to be cared for. There are actual overarching trends on this network against Black people, but this one moderation incident on mastodon.social isn't it, and the conclusion you drew from it is not as motivating as you think it is to address systemic racism throughout the network.