Elektrine lite

← Feed

@dialecticalmusings@app.wafrn.net

2026-06-22 03:23 UTC

@cwebber@social.coop @innocentzero@social.tchncs.de @ricci@discuss.systems I did say … legally responsible for moderating the entire slice of the Fediverse visible to their instance. so I am aware that a Fedi instance owner does not have to literally moderate the entire network. :-) Why is the increase in moderation load (necessarily) linear though? Say, I am an instance owner, and a new user joins my instance. If she follows the conventional Fedi wisdom (“you are your own algorithm—follow a LOT of people and build a rich feed”) and immediately follows a lot of users from other instances, and if many of those users post a lot, and/or boost a lot, then all those posts will now land on my instance, and I am legally responsible for moderating them. Similarly, if my new user starts boosting a lot of posts from other instances, then I am responsible for moderating those too. So at least in this hypothetical example, the moderation load increases exponentially. Of course, in case of an inactive user, the load may not increase at all. I think the more important point is the uncertainty of not knowing what new stuff from other instances may suddenly start landing in your storage. (When I earlier said “more or less the entire network”, it’s this uncertainty that I had in mind.) Your existing user may start following some toxic person, and suddenly in comes the deluge. You may not have the bandwidth to look at some moderation report, and by the time you get round to it, the issue may have blown up. In comparison, an admin/owner has a lot more authority and control over their own users, so there isn’t as much anxiety. My only point was this: a PDS owner in the ATProto world does NOT have to moderate stuff originating on any other PDS. In the ActivityPub world, this option does not exist. To a lot of people, this difference matters. By the way, you said: If you want to form a community, with standards, you either need to run an appview, in which case you are truly moderating the entire network, not just the portion your users interact with … I was under the impression that a PDS can directly communicate with another PDS without the need of an intermediary relay or AppView. Isn’t that correct? So couldn’t someone host a PDS + AppView (no relay), directly communicate with a small number of PDSs, and have their AppView show only those conversations? Wouldn’t this PDS + AppView setup be the equivalent of a Fedi instance? I could be wrong, but I believe wafrn does something like this on the ATProto end. Regarding your broader argument: I agree with you that moderation is a critical part of community building. (A corporate executive may say that in case of social media, moderation is the product.) I also know that moderation is a social + political + economic exercise, in addition to being a technical measure. Personally, I think we need to urgently imagine what ought to be the political economy of social media. Is the Fediverse a public utility? If yes, who is providing the public utility? The state? Which state? Or some NGO? Some philanthropist? To whom is the public utility being provided? Or is the Fediverse a market of commodities? If yes, who is selling those commodities? To whom? One can ask similar questions about the ATmosphere. (The movers and shakers in that world seem to imagine it as a market of commodities, as you point out. But that may be just Americans on autopilot, there may be no deep thought behind it.) The questions of moderation and community building are deeply entangled with the questions of political economy. People arguing about moderation and community building often have fundamentally differing visions for the political economy of the Fediverse, but those differences never get unpacked, so people end up talking past each other. #ATProto #Bluesky #ActivityPub #Fediverse #Mastodon #wafrn

Replies (3)

  • @ricci@discuss.systems 2026-06-22 03:32

    @dialecticalmusings @cwebber@social.coop @innocentzero@social.tchncs.de The reason it's linear is that if each user interacts with N other accounts, two users interact with 2N accounts, three with 3N accounts, and so on - this is linear scaling. Of course the Ns will be different for different users depending on their activity, and it's actually likely to be sub-linear since some of your local accounts are interacting with the same remote accounts, but this is the basic principle.

    Open ##5120014

  • @ricci@discuss.systems 2026-06-22 03:40

    @dialecticalmusings @cwebber@social.coop @innocentzero@social.tchncs.de > I was under the impression that a PDS can directly communicate with another PDS without the need of an intermediary relay or AppView. Isn’t that correct? This is not correct from the "pure" atproto viewpoint. A PDS is simply a store of records, it has no user interface, it has only an API that users use to create and maintain their records (posts, etc.) and a streaming API for others to get copies of those records. The only visible interaction that users have with their PDS is the oauth login flow. Think of it like an s3 bucket, if that is meaningful to you. In this context, it makes no sense for PDSes to talk to each other. Wafrn looks much more like the "instance" that the author of this article calls nonsensical in the atproto world, because it combines several things, including the store of many users' data including users who are not "local", the web interface and/or APIs that users access it with, and more. Wafrn does work in this world, but it is very much in opposition to the architecture the article at the root of this thread is claiming as the "correct" use and understanding of atproto.

    Open ##5120019

  • @ricci@discuss.systems 2026-06-22 03:52

    @dialecticalmusings @cwebber@social.coop @innocentzero@social.tchncs.de > Personally, I think we need to urgently imagine what ought to be the political economy of social media. Is the Fediverse a public utility? If yes, who is providing the public utility? The state? Which state? Or some NGO? Some philanthropist? To whom is the public utility being provided? Strongly agree - the political economy used by atproto - as described in the blog post - is exactly the same one used by Twitter/X, Facebook, Instagram, and all of the other big tech companies. The "app" is a centralized thing, a product, that may have many stakeholders, but has one owner. Yes, they may provide you with some moderation tools Facebook doesn't give you, but at the end of the day, there is an owner of the app, and their moderation is enforced for all users of that app, regardless of what their PDS is on (Bluesky bans users from their appview, regardless of the user's PDS, for violations of their ToS). That is what you are outsourcing to when you run your own PDS but use their appview. What is decentralized in the architecture shown in this blog post - which is the generally-agreed-on use of atproto - is *just* storage. This makes no appreciable difference to the political economy. Now, both Blacksky and wafrn break this "typical" atproto architecture, in different ways. Blacksky does so by running a copy of (almost) the entire network (as well as other things like a more open governance process). In the blog author's diagram, it is basically another app, which happens to have functionality and network visibility that are very similar to the Bluesky app. wafrn breaks it more by building the "instance" that the author of the post doesn't think anyone should think of, combining the app and storage in a way that looks much more like the fediverse. The fediverse (including wafrn here) provide the opportunity to experiment with fundamentally different political economies than the big tech companies have built. atproto (as understood by the author of this blog post, and as generally discussed) does not.

    Open ##5120025