Elektrine lite

← Feed

@ricci@discuss.systems

2026-06-22 03:52 UTC

@dialecticalmusings @cwebber@social.coop @innocentzero@social.tchncs.de > Personally, I think we need to urgently imagine what ought to be the political economy of social media. Is the Fediverse a public utility? If yes, who is providing the public utility? The state? Which state? Or some NGO? Some philanthropist? To whom is the public utility being provided? Strongly agree - the political economy used by atproto - as described in the blog post - is exactly the same one used by Twitter/X, Facebook, Instagram, and all of the other big tech companies. The "app" is a centralized thing, a product, that may have many stakeholders, but has one owner. Yes, they may provide you with some moderation tools Facebook doesn't give you, but at the end of the day, there is an owner of the app, and their moderation is enforced for all users of that app, regardless of what their PDS is on (Bluesky bans users from their appview, regardless of the user's PDS, for violations of their ToS). That is what you are outsourcing to when you run your own PDS but use their appview. What is decentralized in the architecture shown in this blog post - which is the generally-agreed-on use of atproto - is *just* storage. This makes no appreciable difference to the political economy. Now, both Blacksky and wafrn break this "typical" atproto architecture, in different ways. Blacksky does so by running a copy of (almost) the entire network (as well as other things like a more open governance process). In the blog author's diagram, it is basically another app, which happens to have functionality and network visibility that are very similar to the Bluesky app. wafrn breaks it more by building the "instance" that the author of the post doesn't think anyone should think of, combining the app and storage in a way that looks much more like the fediverse. The fediverse (including wafrn here) provide the opportunity to experiment with fundamentally different political economies than the big tech companies have built. atproto (as understood by the author of this blog post, and as generally discussed) does not.

Replies (1)

  • @innocentzero@social.tchncs.de @ricci@discuss.systems @cwebber@social.coop Within the boundaries for this thread indirectly set by Dan Abramov’s blog post, I agree with you. I would argue that even in terms of data ownership, the argument of ATProto fans is not as robust as they imagine. All those narratives about data ownership talk about an individual “owning” his data, which obviously derives from today’s socioeconomic system imagining society as a collection of atomised individual consumers. So the ATProto narrative about PDS says that each individual user owns the record of their posts and their connections. But in the real world, most digital data is meaningful and useful only within its larger social context. For example, if I can read this post alone ten years down the line, with no access to posts by others in this thread, then it won’t make much sense to me. Even for targeted advertisements, the data about an individual is only meaningful in the context of the social group the individual belongs to (“30-35 year old married woman with two kids, employed, spouse employed, stays in Berlin”). Same for policymakers looking at census/survey data. So a Fedi instance actually pulling all the threads of conversations its users are involved in is a more meaningful design of “the instance as community” collectively owning that data. So far, so good. However, the legal setup in most countries does not even recognize a loose collective, let alone allow it to own and run an instance. That is without even getting into the questions of national (judicial) boundaries and the funds for running an instance. So most Fedi instances are run by high-earning technophiles. They remain dependent on the goodwill and mental bandwidth of the owner(s) and on donations by well-to-do users. Only the instance owner(s) own/control the data that belongs to the community. There is no design, even at the technical level, for the community to ditch the owner and migrate (together, as a community) to another instance. Overall, this model of a Fedi instance is very fragile at multiple levels. (I am not even getting into communities that cut across multiple instances.) At the scale of multiple instances, we can immediately see that today this model is bound to remain limited to the Western world. Most of the countries in the global south do not have sufficient number of high-earning individuals (in proportion to their population sizes) who can also run Fedi instances. Neither do they have sufficient number of users who can pay/donate. (The tiny size of the Fedi indicates that even in the Western world, the number of individuals able and willing to run/support Fedi instances is very low.) So the Fedi is bound to remain a tiny white suburbia, with all of its accompanying pathologies (which further repel brown and black people from the West as well as from the global south). (Stray thought: Maybe we should imagine instances analogous to public libraries + discussion rooms. In that case, we want administrators and moderators as paid employees answerable to the larger community, not themselves being “owners”. But even then, the question of a sustainable funding model remains.) So… in the larger context, the enormous inequality across the world and between the global north/south is the core reason why most people cannot get out of free centralized social media services, even if they want to. That’s THE reason why Bluesky has a far larger user base than the Fedi, and why Instagram or Facebook have orders of magnitude larger user bases than even Bluesky. Debates about the relative merits of ActivityPub and ATProto are no doubt useful, but they make no difference to this larger context. (This is not a criticism of your post, just a general point applicable to all such discussions. I am simply flagging the larger context, I have no easy solutions.) #ATProto #Bluesky #ActivityPub #Fediverse #Mastodon

    Open ##5120026