Elektrine lite

← Feed

@fraggle@social.coop

Post #1018991

2026-04-01 21:18 UTC

Boosted this earlier but I'm going to repost for good measure. Kids have been being taught to read wrong for years based on debunked theories that taught them to skip over words, guess at what's written or rely on pictures instead of actually reading the words. Incredible that anyone ever thought this was a good idea, and in parts of the US it's still being taught. https://www.apmreports.org/episode/2019/08/22/whats-wrong-how-schools-teach-reading

Replies (4)

  • @fraggle@social.coop 2026-04-01 21:22

    This post is from 2019 so it's a bit old now, and attention to the issue over the past few years has apparently helped to improve things somewhat now. The Sold a Story Podcast has explored the issue in depth - I've not had the chance to listen to it yet but have seen multiple recommendations https://features.apmreports.org/sold-a-story/

    Open ##1735513

  • @fraggle This is amazingly stupid. But a great opportunity for scammers and the like, I guess? Just put reassuring pictures next the text telling customers how they'll get screwed over, and many will just make up a nice story. Don't even need to bury the nasty parts in a 100 page EULA that no one reads!

    Open ##1735521

  • @rnd@toot.cat 2026-04-01 22:20

    @fraggle i remember reading some years ago that a bunch of right-wing pro-homeschooling people in the u.s. decided that the "whole language" approach to reading, the one that includes the flawed "cueing" idea, was a conspiracy to instill "moral relativism" in children, and as a result, phonics became strongly associated with homeschooling i can imagine this at least partly lead to educators wanting to defend the "whole language" approach and just to make sure, the conspiracists only picked what turned out to be the actually-better method of teaching kids to read by accident but i feel like a lot of well-intentioned people would have a harder time changing their mind if that meant agreeing on the basic premise, even if for entirely different reasons, with the people who think that evolution is fake

    Open ##1735522

  • @easeout@mastodon.social 2026-04-02 00:23

    @fraggle My mother, once a grade school teacher, told me a story of visiting a class after a career change to check the children's vision. While waiting, she observed the teacher prompting the kids, "What do you do when you read a word you don't know?" In chorus: "Read around it!" Shock and horror. This was maybe fifteen years ago.

    Open ##1735523