Elektrine lite

← Feed

@marsiposa@social.coop

2026-10-23 03:21 UTC

@JessicaAnnEng@tech.lgbt in college, I had a required class in animal taxonomy. Some old-school teachers used the field trip to collect large amount of animals for their collections at the natural institute. We, the students, raised our concerns about the unnecessary killing of animals and were met with negatives. I thought it was horrible, but also, my upbringing was one to "do what the teacher says". One of the students, though, plainly refused. She was told she'd fail the field portion of the class. She was an A+ student, this could be very bad for her GPA. After some struggle she said "OK, I'll fail the field part of the class". And she did. That semester she did not get the top GPA. That was more than 20 years ago. Nowadays she's a published researcher in one of the top science institutes in Europe. That was but a blip in her career, but perhaps the most important lesson in ethics in research I ever had.

Replies (2)

  • @marsiposa@social.coop 2026-10-23 03:32

    @JessicaAnnEng@tech.lgbt and just in case you don't feel ok reading about the CW'ed topic, the bottom of the story is that college is much more than the grades. Yes, it doesn't feel like that, and for practical purposes grades do matter a lot. But in the long arc of gaining education for your life, there is a lot of learning that does not involve grades. Sometimes the right answer involves getting a bad grade, particularly when topics of ethics are involved. As a former college instructor, I support your daughter.

    Open ##5354057

  • @amphianna@mastodonapp.uk 2026-10-23 09:09

    @marsiposa@social.coop @JessicaAnnEng@tech.lgbt I'm surprised that was as little as 20 years ago. There are international regulations now preventing collecting from the wild without strict controls, as I'm sure you know. Good on your classmate - this kind of thing is hard to resist when it seems like everyone is doing it.

    Open ##5354058