Elektrine lite

← Feed

@ricci@discuss.systems

2026-06-20 06:13 UTC

@innocentzero@social.tchncs.de mmmm.... I think in a world without relays, it's actually the PDSes that suffer more, unless there are very few apps/appviews. The total bandwidth the app has to ingest (assuming it wants the whole network view) is basically the same whether you are pulling from a relay or from a bunch of individual PDSes; it's more websockets, which has a cost, but manageable. However, right each PDS only has to *upload* to a fairly small number of relays and a few oddball applications that connect to it directly (actually I run my own PDS, I should check this :). Without a relay, the PDS has to serve every app individually. I think one thing that has become clear to me in discussions this evening is that many atproto developers are assuming a world with not very many apps, why is why they are not very concerned about this.

Replies (1)

  • @ricci@discuss.systems Ah, that makes sense, I was thinking more along the lines of relays collecting all that data and then aggregating it (do relays do it?) Also, I have this eternal confusion on whether relays pull from PDSes or PDSes push to relays. If it's the latter, how do new relays advertise themselves to the PDSes?

    Open ##5120047