Post #4347813
2026-08-03 07:13 UTC
a concrete example of why Classical Chinese is an unintelligble nightmare when spoken aloud by modern dictionary rules:
何 "why?" (one syllable)
何不 "why not?" (two syllables)
盍 a one-syllable contraction for casually saying "why not?"
In ancient pronunciation, roughly: "ha, ha pu, hap."
But Modern Mandarin has lost final -p in all words. Which leaves you with...?
With Classical "何 why?" and "盍 why not?" being pronounced exactly the same: "hé"
This is why modern native speakers hate Classical Chinese in literature class 😂
#classicalchinese #linguistics
Replies (1)
-
@0xabad1dea@infosec.exchange 2026-08-03 07:28
I expect Cantonese kids have an easier time with this sort of thing because they didn't lose all their consonants under the couch cushions