Post #1916692
2023-01-05 15:34 UTC
@drmaxlwilson i'd love to know what reviewers think their job is… i tend to approach it as raise ~only the major issues that need to be addressed for the paper to be published, so that authors can try to address them… i'm one of those 8 review (but short, probably the 400 word average person). what are people doing with 1000 words? every once in a while i get a long review that concludes with a long list of all the typos in the paper, and … i don't think i'm going to be doing that! haha.
Replies (1)
-
@drmaxlwilson@hci.social 2023-01-05 15:42
@jbigham true. If it’s only 1000 words because it’s every missing comma listed, then it’s not so great.