Elektrine lite

← Feed

@paniash@mstdn.social

Post #1782171

2026-04-28 21:17 UTC

Curious to know what the majority of #emacs users use for the keybindings i.e. vanilla or modal editing (evil, meow, etc.). Coming from vim, it's hard to get rid of evil and it almost always conflicts with emacs packages where the author did not intend for modal keybindings to work. (1/2)

Replies (7)

  • @paniash@mstdn.social 2026-04-28 21:18

    I'm currently looking at meow since they state in their readme: "Meow aims to blend modal editing into Emacs with minimal interference with its original key-bindings, avoiding most of the hassle introduced by key-binding conflicts." Looks like it might be a smoother transition from evil compared to directly moving to vanilla bindings. (2/2) Interested to hear what package authors use too: @tarsius@fosstodon.org @minad@mastodon.world @oantolin@mathstodon.xyz @yantar92@fosstodon.org #emacs

    Open ##2777471

  • @gecht@chaos.social 2026-04-29 06:32

    @paniash@mstdn.social Evil by default for me, and has been for more than a decade. But I do use the occasional non-evil keybinding. Honestly, just whatever works for me in the moment. I think I’ve learned to stress less about trying to optimise the last percentile of my productivity at this point!

    Open ##2777514

  • @jaredj@mastodon.bsd.cafe 2026-04-30 15:34

    @paniash@mstdn.social i use devil-mode, which is vanilla-er than meow. i've also used meow, boon, and xah-fly-keys. for me it wasn't just the key bindings themselves being unsupported by add-on packages - it was that there were major modes where the modality itself was screwed up, and e.g. i couldn't type a letter 'x' in a vc changelog message because it was almost but not quite in insert mode. Maybe I wasn't sufficiently init-bankrupt before trying it? Anyway I've been pretty happy with devil-mode for a few years now

    Open ##2777515

  • @harish@hachyderm.io 2026-05-01 16:29

    @paniash@mstdn.social I’ve been using Emacs since I was a teen and I’ve only used the vanilla key-bindings.

    Open ##2777517

  • @paniash@mstdn.social I use boon which I made pretty close to emscs keybindings, only modal. This way I don’t have to switch into command mode all the time.

    Open ##2777518

  • @brettm@swarm.coiloptic.org 2026-05-03 10:26

    @paniash@mstdn.social recently switched from vis to emacs. i just use default emacs keybindings, except for ctrl+j to enable multiline edit, which matches vis

    Open ##2777519

  • @tusharhero@mathstodon.xyz 2026-05-03 17:14

    @paniash@mstdn.social vanilla, I nuked many of my custom keybindings a whole ago(before that I used to use evil.) I have a personal rule that if a keybinding already exists, I will only use that keybinding and not rebind it.

    Open ##2777520