Post #1621468

2026-04-17 04:14 UTC

I would argue it does not directly or obviously impact device ownership. However, to the best of my knowledge, it would be the first time that the US Government has publicly required a specific set of features for consumer software. To make matters worse, this is an Operating System level requirement, which means it has more permissions than any other piece of software you run. Every device you run today has an Operating System of some kind, so this bill could impact all devices. So, I think the conclusion that you no longer own the device stems from the fact that it has software on it doing things and collecting information you did not approve. For normal people, there will be no way to avoid it. Tech savvy users will of course find ways to dodge it unless there are enforcement mechanisms and penalties that are sufficiently punitive. Definitely not a path we should be going down if we actually cared about freedom, much less privacy. Not to mention, this opens up the whole “slippery slope” argument for more direct government control over software.

Replies (3)

@tabarnaski@sh.itjust.works 2026-04-17 04:30

It could be a dangerous path indeed, giving the government full access to your phone. I’m not sure the bill says that though. But I think most people already do… A huge bunch of apps collect everything they can on you; tiktok used to be the worst. I wouldn’t trust a government less than a private company. I dunno, maybe forcing companies to put (or remove) specific features on their software could set an interesting legal precedent: it could be used to stop companies from pushing features people don’t want or designing apps with dark patterns.

Open ##1623344
@dev_null@lemmy.ml 2026-04-17 05:57

To make matters worse, this is an Operating System level requirement, which means it has more permissions than any other piece of software you run That’s not a given, it could easily be implemented as a normal application with normal permissions, that the OS starts when needed.

Open ##1630058
@backalleycoyote@lemmy.today 2026-04-17 08:52

Every device you run today has an Operating System of some kind, so this bill could impact all devices. Not all devices. God bless these chucklefucks for targeting the tools of the 1st instead of the tools of the 2nd. Why use words when you can use lead?

Open ##1639231