Post #1316082
2024-11-22 15:16 UTC
The peer review system no longer works to guarantee academic rigour - a different approach is needed https://theconversation.com/the-peer-review-system-no-longer-works-to-guarantee-academic-rigour-a-different-approach-is-needed-244092
In this piece @stephenpinfield, Kathy Zeiler and I make the case for the publish-review-curate model, the model we use in the #MetaROR (MetaResearch Open Review) platform launched earlier this week.
For more details about MetaROR's publish-review-curate model, see https://metaror.org/publish-review-curate/.
@RoRInstitute @aimos @cwts
Replies (2)
-
@nichtich@openbiblio.social 2024-11-23 08:05
@LudoWaltman@social.cwts.nl @stephenpinfield@mstdn.social @RoRInstitute@indieweb.social @aimos@masto.ai @cwts@social.cwts.nl there are guidelines for authors, guidelines for reviewers but what about guidelines for curators?
-
@mike@sauropods.win 2024-11-23 08:34
@LudoWaltman@social.cwts.nl @stephenpinfield@mstdn.social @RoRInstitute@indieweb.social @aimos@masto.ai @cwts@social.cwts.nl "The peer review system no longer works to guarantee academic rigour ." It never did. Its primary value has always been the imposition of a barrier which real scientists are sufficiently motivated to climb over, but cranks are not.