@NathanHarvey@kolektiva.social
2025-05-09 19:40 UTC
@highergeometer @TobyBartels @sibrosan I wouldn’t be able to accurately represent Wildberger’s objections to sqrt(2), but I can start with the fifth root of 7 to give a better idea here.
Well, first actually let me start again with fractions. With fractions, we have finite processes to give us real world implementations of them. For interpretations on distance, for example, we have the classic straightedge and compass techniques. We can show that a finite set of steps is expected to give an interpretation of a fraction in the world, and we can have tolerances on the actual engineering implementation that shows the properties of that fraction are obeyed to tolerance.
For fifth root 7, we don’t have a clear way to understand that in the world within our finite comprehension. At least not one I see immediately. I know of infinite processes that are meant to represent that, and I know truncation can give arbitrary precision, but that truncated process isn’t a representation of fifth root 7, and we can demonstrate that it wouldn’t be equal.
Notice here, the process for representing the number is what we interact for proof. That’s kind of the hidden point behind BHK semantics in the wider constructivist philosophy. We can demonstrate a finite process for many fractions in the world, though obviously many fractions we wouldn’t have experience of and may find it unobtainable, so an ultrafinitist would also typically object to asserting their existence too. The process has to actually exist for the numbers to exist. Existence is semantic. But we can see why we may have blanket statements about the nonexistence for something like fifth root of 7.
Now, decimal expansions to me are always a little distracting. I think the fact that numbers can have decimal representations gets confused with the idea that all philosophies have to place that existence as fundamental to the concept of number, and that’s odd and incorrect to me. Other representations exist, and those may be the real world interpretation. 1/3 has a finite representation and finite process of construction, but there are often long divergences of discussions around the fact it has an infinite decimal representation. Every natural number also has infinite representations (like the infinite list of its mod(p) values), but that’s not meaningful to ultrafinitists and not a problem to their philosophy. What is true goes the other way: if something has a finite decimal representation then it also is rational and has a finite fraction representation. So it sometimes gets used as a test, but I think that kind of talk often confuses the story because it sounds like that is a requirement when it usually isn’t.
Now with sqrt(2), though, there is a finite construction that brings it to experience in the construction of a square. So if the only criteria is achievable process in the world, then it seems square roots exist as well. In fact, I think this was a big part of the Pythagorean Crisis in mathematical philosophy, that existence wasn’t entirely rational. I think when you include real world concepts like strings, even some transcendentals like pi exist.
And I will say this is where I start to personally have differences with certain common strains of ultrafinitism, but it is also important to recognise that Wildberger acknowledges/recognizes this claim for square roots, and he has philosophy around it. His rational geometry is built on the idea that distance is not the “fundamental” quantity of metric geometry, but instead it is distance squared that is meaningful and exists. He has expanded on this in quite a lot of detail over the years. Even if I personally don’t feel convinced by his approach, I recognise that I may not understand the argument and acknowledge that he does seek to address it.
It’s also an interesting aside that when I developed my own theory of classical mechanics that didn’t reify space, I used Euclidean Distance Matrices (EDMs) as the information store for interparticle relationships, and EDMs use the distance squared. I’m not saying that so much as support for Wildberger’s position as just showing that I do have an affinity for at least considering the foundational role of distance squared, and that I don’t find rational geometry as an absurd step to address the existence of irrationals.
Replies (0)
No replies.