2024-07-26 14:24 UTC
Pylons are not so much the price for cheaper electricity as they are the price of living beyond our means. Electricity should be generated near to where it is used. One of the problems with the current renewables gold rush is that it allows the concentrated overconsumption of our urban centres to ingress yet farther afield than in the past; it further expands our invasive species’ conquest of new spaces: a land occupied by a pylon is forever tainted, bearing the hallmark of being damaged, and with it an invitation to future abused.
One of the particularly insidious aspects of pushing our energy generation further away from where we live, and even out into the sea, is it conceals from us the reality of our lifestyles, it transforms reality into an impersonal abstraction, and such abstractions are invariably easy to justify.
It is easy to dismiss objections to pylons as nothing more than nymbism, but nimbyism is an entirely valid response to nimbyism itself -- there is absolutely nothing wrong with refusing to carry undersirable consequences for those who do not want to face up to them themselves.
I have very little doubt that future generations (assuming there will be many) will look at our carefree deployment of renewables at massive scale with the same horror they will view our love affair with oil and gas; we are not solving the core problems of our existence, merely transforming them into a different space, one that at present might seem to us less problematic, not least because our criteria are constrained ad absurdum. But no activity at a huge scale is ever without dramatic consequences. Scale is everything, and nothing ever scales infinitely.
Replies (0)
No replies.