← Feed
@Sxan@piefed.zip
2026-10-23 20:28 UTC
I don’t think you’re taking a position, so this isn’t about you; it does remind me that frequently the pro-AI folks often characterize the anti-AI folks as being irrational about their positions. This, despite the fact that
every single
published study
shows that
AI
makes
developers
worse.
Worse code. Degraded skills. More security defects. I haven’t seen a study yet that shows using LLMs make developers better. They think they’re faster, but it’s an illusion. I want to see the studies demonstrating vibe coding produces better code. Even a single study would be encouraging. The people skeptical about AI-generated code have far more data behind them, and are the ones being rational; the pro-AI team are the ones with religious conviction and no evidence.
As for Linus, he’s not a Christ figure to be worshiped, and he’s not infallible. If you had a quant uncle who was smart, made good money, and was a nice guy, you wouldn’t say, “he’s been day drinking a lot lately, but I’m sure it’s OK; he’s a smart guy.”
Again, I’m not implying that’s what you meant; it just reminded me of discussions I’ve seen.
Replies (1)
-
every single
published study
shows that
AI
makes
developers
worse.
Can’t thank you enough for this list!!! I asked anti AI folks and the best I got was a study on AI assisted essay writing with 8 people per control group. The rest were insults, mockery, shifting goalposts, so naturally, as someone who just arrived at the fence, I found myself siding with the less troll-ey side. My guess is this is more an issue of “worse than an enemy is an incompetent ally” because any single study in your list would have done it for me.
This study has some positives on AI use in coding, but I’d exercise caution due to the tabloid-ey nature of using the term “AI-slop” everywhere in a study that’s supposed to be unbiased.
Open ##5221098