Elektrine lite

← Feed

@GrumpyRabbit@social.teci.world

2026-09-26 00:57 UTC

@amerika@annihilation.social @Bernard@friends.ravergram.club re: "Life is about using what you have to get what you need." Exactly. I don't know of any AnCaps, Voluntaryists or libertarians who won't use state-maintained roads, or courts, or police, or public libraries, or just about any other public service, just because the (very illegitimate!) state operates and/or subsidizes them. The correct solution to the Trolley Problem depends on what the stakes--and holistically-relevant consequences of the chosen action--happen to be. To conflate actions that are intended as tactical with ones that are intended as strategic is a category error. It's logically fallacious to wrongfully equate voting for a candidate or policy for the tactical purpose of defending against encroaching tyranny with strategic (deontological) support for the state simply because, in general, support for a democratic republic is ethically equivalent to supporting the validity/rightfulness of having a monopoly provider of justice and security. Those are distinct categories. The strategic/deontological position is about the intrinsic validity of the institution itself: the claim that a territorial monopoly on the legitimate use of force is not merely a contingent historical accident or a pragmatic necessity, but a rightful, principled feature of social order. Conflating the two collapses the distinction between: * "I will use this lever despite its flawed design, because the alternative lever is worse in the short run," and * "This lever's design is the correct one; the monopoly it embodies is ethically proper." Those two stances belong to entirely different logical types. One is a judgment about outcomes in a non-ideal world; the other is a judgment about the ideal itself. Treating participation in the former as evidence of endorsement of the latter is like saying that a prisoner who files an appeal within the warden's rules thereby affirms the warden's right to imprison him. The categories don't touch.

Replies (5)

  • @GrumpyRabbit@social.teci.world @amerika@annihilation.social All government is authoritarian, but we cannot function as a nation without government. The current government works through manipulating our minds into conformity with what it wants. As more people break out of the manipulation hold, more heavy handed approaches are employed. The future is right wing authoritarianism or left wing authoritarianism. Choose your side.

    Open ##4851266

  • @s8n@posting.lolicon.rocks 2026-09-26 14:40

    @amerika@annihilation.social @Bernard@friends.ravergram.club @GrumpyRabbit@social.teci.world counterpoint: we cast votes into machines that we know are rooted and easy to hack

    Open ##5442652

  • @amerika@annihilation.social @Bernard@friends.ravergram.club @GrumpyRabbit@social.teci.world The process by which parties internally select candidates and bend primaries is something I don't think most normies pay much attention to. I mean, damn, most people don't even care about who their city commissioner or sheriff or judges are... Whether they have political bumper stickers or even attend political demonstrations... Even politicians must bend over for their party, vis a vis the party whip Biggest thing the parties care about is making money, whether by grifting before elections or meeting with lobbyists, &c :20bux:

    Open ##5442654

  • @Zeb@merovingian.club 2026-09-26 15:06

    @amerika@annihilation.social @Bernard@friends.ravergram.club @GrumpyRabbit@social.teci.world Wait, what? You believe in voting and democracy?

    Open ##5442655

  • @Zeb@merovingian.club 2026-09-26 16:01

    @amerika@annihilation.social @Bernard@friends.ravergram.club @GrumpyRabbit@social.teci.world I often hate that we have to use these message boards. No, I meant believe in as in thinking it's an effective way of ruling to promote the values of the society/groups that form that "voting block"? I don't care if things are good, bad or evil. That's not how power and ruling works. What determines what happens is what those in power decide is going to happen - unles they're challenged by others with power. Voting and democracy ignores this natural reality.

    Open ##5442656