2026-06-28 01:15 UTC
@dyckron
It is an uncomfortable truth that our political and economic systems are locked in a paradox where restoring housing affordability directly threatens the asset wealth of an older generation. But two structural engines ignored by the mainstream drive the crisis, namely financialization and our obsession with GDP growth.
To truly understand why improved affordability seems to prevent home building, we have to look past simple supply and demand charts and confront how money is created and what our economy is actually designed to measure.
Mainstream economists treat housing prices as a function of physical supply and population growth. But, as Michael Hudson points out, the price of real estate is mostly not determined by the cost of bricks and mortar. Rather, housing prices are largely driven by how much money a bank is willing to lend against it.
When banks deregulated and shifted their focus from financing productive industrial capacity to fueling real estate speculation, they turned housing into a massive debt-fueled bubble.
In the bidding war for urban land, commercial banks consistently favor landlords and institutional corporate investors over workingclass families. Banks lend to landlords based on projected rental income, allowing investors to take on massive leverage that an ordinary wage earner simply cannot match.
This flood of easy credit doesn't build more homes. It merely bids up the price of the land underneath them. The resulting high land prices act as an extractive land rent. It's a tax levied by the financial sector on the rest of society.
When Kershaw notes that building deeply affordable housing is financially prohibitive for developers, it is because developers aren't just paying for lumber and labor, they are paying a massive premium for land that has been artificially inflated by bank credit. If we don’t restrict the flow of speculative credit to landlords, building more supply is just throwing dry wood onto a financial bonfire.
The second deeper structural barrier is our dogmatic reliance on Gross Domestic Product (GDP) as a proxy for societal health. As Jason Hickel points out, GDP is a metric of aggregate throughput, i.e. it measures how fast we can transform nature and human labor into commodities and cash. It is entirely indifferent to whether those commodities actually satisfy human needs.
The housing crisis is a feature, not a bug, of a GDP obsessed economy.
If a developer builds luxury condos that sit empty as speculative assets for foreign capital, GDP goes up. If corporate landlords consolidate the housing stock and hike rents by 30%, GDP goes up because rental expenditure increases.
Conversely, if we were to build deeply affordable non-market co-ops designed solely to provide stable shelter, GDP growth would stall in that sector. Because our politicians and economists are terrified of a dipping GDP line, they favor market driven, high margin developments over the zero-growth or decommodified solutions that would actually solve the crisis.
We must embrace a degrowth framework that explicitly decouples human wellbeing from aggregate economic growth. A society's success should not be measured by the total market value of its real estate portfolio, but by its ability to guarantee basic human needs like housing, nutrition, and healthcare.
Kershaw is entirely correct that we are addicted to rising home prices. But that addiction is maintained because our financial system relies on real estate debt to create money, and our political class relies on real estate inflation to fake GDP growth.
Until we limit the banking sector's ability to subsidize landlords over citizens, and until we stop treating housing as a speculative asset to pump up national growth metrics, improved affordability will remain an economic impossibility. We have to stop building for the market, and start building for human beings.
Replies (0)
No replies.