Elektrine lite

← Feed

@redditStinksSuperBad@lemmy.world

2026-09-23 00:56 UTC

What you said was “I don’t care if they target a government agency I don’t like - they’re just another bunch of assholes out to make a profit.” not “even if they attack someone I don’t like, I still won’t celebrate it because I know what their motivation is.”. In or out of context, "I don’t care if they target a government agency I don’t like"means the exact same thing. It’s a stand alone statement not impacted by your second sentence. Your rephrasing makes more sense and the two parts of your sentence can not be separated without changing the meaning.

Replies (1)

  • @luciferofastora@feddit.org 2026-09-23 07:45

    In or out of context, "I don’t care if they target a government agency I don’t like"means the exact same thing. It’s a stand alone statement not impacted by your second sentence. That’s just not true. The fact that it can form a complete sentence on its own doesn’t divorce its meaning from the surrounding context. In my favourite example, “I want to make sure the children die with the parent” is a complete sentence, but outside of a programming context, it’s quite fucked up. In this case, the sentence you quoted is equivalent to a parenthetical to add nuance to the second half you omitted: “They’re just another bunch of assholes out to make a profit (even if they target a government agency I don’t like).” It’s the opposite of a standalone statement: It’s the subordinate qualification to a different, standalone statement. Just because you can quote it outside its context doesn’t mean that it’s independent of context.

    Open ##4903513