@NathanHarvey@kolektiva.social
2025-05-07 16:10 UTC
@highergeometer @TobyBartels @sibrosan When many radical constructivists use the word “meaningful”, they mean this formally as having reference (in reality or experience). Some numbers have natural interpretation in real experience - counting and fractions are processes we participate with in the world, which is what makes them “meaningful”. But no one ever actually does infinite processes. No one has ever experienced them.
This idea of “meaningfulness” is critical to the syntax/model distinction we make, and these philosophical positions were discussed in depth by people like Tarski in giving us modern metamathematics. Calling it “silly” is dismissive of a lot of foundational thought.
Replies (0)
No replies.