Elektrine lite

← Feed

@schnoopy@awful.systems

2026-09-04 06:25 UTC

So I love Neal’s books, I think he’s a fun story-teller and anathems orbital mechanics scene has loads more tension than any slop in something like interstellar. But whenever he gets involved in social-technological commentary I am reminded of Ursala Le Guinn’s remarks on SciFi authors being professional liars, not prophets.

Replies (3)

  • @gerikson@awful.systems 2026-09-04 10:44

    I’m convinced Stephenson is personally very right wing but also smart enough not to advertise it publicly.

    Open ##4617014

  • @picklefactory@awful.systems 2026-09-04 22:18

    The main thing I have noticed, thinking back, is that his books often require an Interesting Billionaire to move the plot forward – Dodge, T.R. Schmidt, Eliza, the sultan of Kinakuta, whatever – and my suspension of disbelief can no longer always rise to the occasion on that count, even in an SF setting. Which is also I think why Anathem remains my favorite.

    Open ##4620914

  • @istewart@awful.systems 2026-09-05 03:32

    I am reminded of Ursala Le Guinn’s remarks on SciFi authors being professional liars, not prophets. The advent of the AI bubble has made this distinction much more trenchant for me. I was already somewhat aware before, but I am now much more likely to judge someone’s character on whether they believe science fiction, broadly, is a roadmap to the future or a reflection and exploration of current conditions and historical contingencies.

    Open ##4621814