2026-09-08 12:50 UTC
Replies (4)
-
@SofaFernsehFan@swiss.social 2026-09-08 13:43
@robinm@fosstodon.org @TheWarOnCars@mastodon.social I once had a self inflicted accident (drunk cycling) that would have ended pretty bad without helmet. No others involved. Therefore: A helmet does NOT prevent accidents but it reduces impact. Of course its always better to reduce the risk of accidents alltogether.
-
@number6@fosstodon.org 2026-09-08 15:27
@robinm@fosstodon.org @SofaFernsehFan@swiss.social @TheWarOnCars@mastodon.social In the Netherlands, if you fall, you will probably land on grass or maybe that almost-spongy bike surface they have. There will not be a car 20 feet behind you. When you fall in the overdeveloped world, it will be on asphalt, and there will be cars behind you. You may have only 5 seconds to haul yourself out of traffic. You don't want to be stunned or unconscious during that period.
-
@HiddenPineapple@infosec.exchange 2026-09-08 15:42
@robinm@fosstodon.org @SofaFernsehFan@swiss.social @TheWarOnCars@mastodon.social Obviously stats are important but without even checking I have a hard time believing helmets aren't effective for cyclists. I think when most people get into bicycle accidents it's obviously better their helmet hit a concrete curb than their skull. Furthermore, it's important to remember there may be some statistical bias in these kinds of studies. The idea that helmets don't have a correlation with reduced injury is probably a skewed stat. Purely speculative, but I'd guess many minor bicycle accidents involving head trauma where a helmet was used, likely don't result in a visit to the hospital and therefore go unreported. If someone went to the hospital for a bicycle injury, a helmet was probably less effective as the accident was more severe requiring medical attention making it appear as though helmets aren't effective. It's important to remember that sometimes it's not about the stats you can count, it's about the ones you don't.
-
@Kazinator@mstdn.ca 2026-09-08 22:36
@robinm@fosstodon.org @SofaFernsehFan@swiss.social @TheWarOnCars@mastodon.social Bike helmets are effective protection in falls. Over the past 15 years, I fell twice in such a way that my helmet hit the pavement. It was a loud sound, like a crack, but I was fine. That would have been my head hitting the pavement without the helmet! An ordinary bicycle helmet might not be effective in a motor vehicle collision, or impacts at high speeds. If you like to go down mountain roads and hit 60 km/h on your road bike, and one day crash such that your head hits something, the helmet will likely not save you. You probably also don't want to use one if you do serious downhill mountain biking; you need a more substantial helmet with face/chin protection.