Post #3840253
2026-07-15 19:43 UTC
Awww, but I like the pure science fiction.
I am most amazed at two aspects… how to put it:
One is just, they don’t know what they are and what the universe is. The idea that things downstream of things like us can push around galaxies never ceases to amaze me. I felt the same way watching the movie Interstellar. They were using chemical rockets to navigate around a supermassive black hole. The gravitational potential between places they occupied in that film was a third of their rest mass. Chemistry means nothing there. FUSION means nothing there.
(to say nothing of the fact that if interstellar travel were possible there would already be replicators and an ecology throughout the universe, but that’s another story)
The second is, things happen because of ideas and agreements rather than actions. You can speak into existence billion year plans for what happens to whole galaxies, and it happens because that is what you said. Laws exist because a bunch of people continue to agree that it’s better for them to act like they do than to do what they CAN do. This is a universe without interactions, without agency of anything but the rich weirdos steering the AI god, without for lack of a better word ecology emerging from the interactions of many agents and resource constraints and capacities.
Replies (1)
-
@scruiser@awful.systems 2026-07-15 22:48
Awww, but I like the pure science fiction. Even as sci-fi, Ai: 2040 is lackluster! Where is the classic lesswrong trope of drexler-style nanotech? Where are the cybernetic augmentations!? The second is, things happen because of ideas and agreements rather than actions. You can speak into existence billion year plans for what happens to whole galaxies, and it happens because that is what you said. It is the same flaw that underlies the cryptobros delusions about blockchains and NFTs. You can make some cryptography ledger, it doesn’t mean anyone actually follows it or that the ledger tracks reality.