@NathanHarvey@kolektiva.social
2025-02-16 20:30 UTC
@highergeometer @johndcook I think the best explanations of this take you on the semantic journey: you have a syntax around equality and are looking for a model to interpret it. This is a fascinating task in the abstract, and there is a lot of great math and philosophy just around concretisation and distinctions of isomorphism and equality, and it gets pretty wild once real world considerations of distinguishability are introduced.
When looking to get students fascinated by interesting equality semantics and help them recognise the proper place of questions of zeta regularization, I always appreciate the ones that lead the students to consider greater connections between syntax and semantics and validate to them such syntax really is mathematical and deeply interesting. So often I see “explanations” that imply a certain wrongness or absurdity to writing such equations, and that approach - though possibly also trying to be instructive - is ultimately destructive.
Replies (0)
No replies.