Elektrine lite

← Feed

@MEtrINeS@lemmy.dbzer0.com

2026-10-05 06:29 UTC

P2P is when users communicate directly. P2P means peer to peer! Definition of peer: 2. countable noun Your peers are the people who are the same age as you or who have the same status as you. His engaging personality made him popular with his peers. Synonyms: equal, like, match, fellow [old-fashioned] More Synonyms of peer “The same status” , Synonyms: equal. This is describing federation and decentralization, not P2P. It’s very similar but not the same. Using lemmy as example, when i request posts from another server, my server will request only those posts. It won’t request everything. Do you see the difference? A CDN is centralized in control but distributed in delivery: one content owner controls the authoritative data, while a CDN operator replicates it across its infrastructure. In p2p nobody controls the authoritative data - if one peer refuses to distribute the data, my server can still get the data from another feed. Both federation or CDNs don’t work in a P2P manner. They either have selective replication and/or centralized control. Usenet has companies running the servers, and you download from and upload to the company’s servers. Again this has nothing to do with being p2p or not. And btw, stop moving the goal posts.

Replies (1)

  • @hirihit640@sh.itjust.works 2026-10-06 21:20

    Using lemmy as example, when i request posts from another server, my server will request only those posts. It won’t request everything. Do you see the difference? That’s just how activitypub works because the alternative would be too costly. But you could design a federation system that replicates everything. A precise description is: Usenet is a distributed system where servers peer with each other to replicate articles (P2P at the server layer), while users interact in a client–server manner with their chosen news provider. Even your perplexity output admits that it’s not fully P2P like bittorrent. And if we count “partial P2P”, then activitypub would also count since even selective replication, is some amount of replication, and tbus “partial P2P”

    Open ##4946635