Elektrine lite

← Feed

@tf@kolektiva.social

2024-04-18 11:13 UTC

Some thoughts on #AI and creativity in #photography A great deal of photographers, not least landscape and nature photographers, are concerned these days about AI, and are voicing the need to be able to differentiate images that are the product of human creative process from those created by AI (and looking for technological solutions to facilitate that); the common assumption being that AI images are inferior, fake and fraudulent. But it seems to me that the big problem in all of this discussion is that the distinction between human creative manipulation and AI is entirely artificial, i.e., if a human artist and an autonomous AI system were to produce an identical image, it would be an identical image; at this point the differentiation between the two has no longer anything to do objectively with the image, but is purely a subjective value judgement regarding agency. Conversely, if we couch the debate in terms of veracity and fraud then the agency doesn’t matter, only the manipulation does, i.e., there is no reason why an AI generated image could not be closer to reality than a creatively manipulated one — the ‘creative’ label stops being meaningful in this context, the image is either objectively faithful (however we choose to define that) to external reality or not. In other words, the defence of ‘human creativity’ against ‘AI’ hinges entirely on where the agency lies with AI generated content, and given that current AI systems are not autonomous, those images still have human agency. So what we are really talking about when we say ‘creativity’ in this context is a value judgement about the tools the artist chooses to use. I might very well greatly value one set of tools over the other, but I think the target audience in general doesn’t care that much. Could we develop a system to indicate the tooling? Most likely. Does it mean that images created without AI will sell better? I suspect not (and I think that’s really what most of the concern is about). I expect at some point in our dystopian future AI could become autonomous, i.e., we could be looking at images generated without any human agency at all, but that doesn’t fundamentally change the nature of these deliberations: it still all comes down to the value assigned to the particular type of agency, and has little to do with objective properties of the image. The real problem for photographic genres such as landscape and nature is not AI per se, it’s the fact that the connection with reality has been severed long time ago in the name of artistic creativity. What the arrival of AI does is merely to create a situation where suddenly even the best can be outdone at this creative game. For the record, I am not a believer in AI. It brings real, multifaceted, problems, the two that concern me most at present is the sheer level of inane noise LLMs generate, and the environmental costs of all these systems. But as far as landscape and nature photography are concerned, we just need to find ways which genuinely give value to the human agency behind our images; if we can’t we deserve all the AI generated content world’s data centres can throw at us.

Replies (0)

No replies.