← Feed
It’s funny cause i was having similar thoughts recently, and pretty much came to the same conclusion, except for me it’s not just gaming. I’m using Guix now and have used NixOS in the past, and i really came to love declaring my entire system through a configuration file, i just love how organized it feels and being able to easily reinstall a very customized system. As far as i’m aware such a thing doesn’t really exist on BSD. I think i read about the Nix package manager having some experimental support for FreeBSD, but it’s not the same as declaring the whole system, so i would have to give that up. It probably wouldn’t be the worst thing in the world, since i also really love Void and its simplicity, so BSD probably wouldn’t be too drastic of a move, but then there’s the gaming aspect, and also, i’m not sure how great hardware support is. I’m not sure about NetBSD, but if i understand correctly, both FreeBSD and OpenBSD port their amdgpu drivers over from Linux, so up until pretty recent AMD cards should be supported depending on the release. AMD processors should also be good to go, so i’m guessing it comes down to wifi as a potential blocker maybe.
Something else i’ve been thinking about is: does it really matter at the end of the day? Because code submitted to the kernel is still held to the same standard whether it was created with the help of an LLM or not. Not only that, but on the BSD side of things, even when they are explicitly anti-AI, if someone submits code that was made with the help of an LLM, and the maintainers are not aware of it, but merge it because the quality of the code is good, wouldn’t it put them in the exact same situation as Linux? The only difference at that point would be that one of them is openly saying they accept it, and the other does not, but in reality basically the same thing happens either way. So i feel like at that point i would only be switching for an ideological difference that can’t really hold up practically, so what’s the point?
Replies (3)
-
If you’re using Guix… doesn’t Guix have a version that uses Hurd? It’s not BSD, but it’s also not Linux. Hurd is one option I’m looking at.
does it really matter at the end of the day?
Yeah, I don’t know. Maybe not. I guess it’s a question of whether my trust in the core Linux maintainers’ development skill translates to trust in their ability to use AI well. There’s pretty good evidence of Dunning-Kruger-like effect where developers over-estimate how good LLM-generated code is, and whether it makes them more productive; is Linus immune to that? I guess I don’t want to get caught with my pants down, and that means not having to scramble if the front falls off the boat.
Open ##5213021
-
Check out Nixbsd. It’s like NixOS, but with FreeBSD kernel instead of Linux. Not sure how usable it is atm though.
Also there’s Astarinas NixOS. Asterinas is a new Linux abi compatible kernel. It is in early development but surely is a promising project.
Open ##5220235
-
so BSD probably wouldn’t be too drastic of a move, but then there’s the gaming aspect,
I tried out FreeBSD probably close to ten years ago now, and there was a compatibility tool for Linux software. I didn’t run it super long, but the gaming experience I had wasn’t very different from the one I had on Linux. Of course, ten years ago, we expected more breakage playing on Linux, so it’s possible I had more errors than I’d have gotten on Linux and just didn’t realize it, in which case, it couldn’t be that much worse.
Open ##5229072