[Critique Wanted] Does the foreground crowd carry this frame or choke it?
2026-05-02 09:12 UTC
Replies (5)
-
@disevani@lemmy.world 2026-05-02 09:24
I think i would prefer a wider aperture here, creating some blur in the crowd. Otherwise, i like this image the way it is! Nicely done.
-
@Ludrol@szmer.info 2026-05-02 11:18
For my amateurish eye there are two crops that I found good.  Here I found a portrait-like framing of the guide. ---  Here I found as if guide stands inside the crown. --- In your picture I don't like that there isn't a primary subject. The painting takes too much space fighting for attention without getting it, having it blended into the crowd. Another solution would be to add color to the paiting as if they are real and we are not. lifting the attention to the painting.
-
@Redfox8@mander.xyz 2026-05-02 12:13
What's the primary subject being photographed here? Is it the painting with the, people secondary or is the guide the subject, or is it the scene as a whole, all parts equal? What style are you going for also? A portrait, a 'street' scene, a documentary/newspaper shot, an artistic shot? These will dictate how much each element may be out of balance. My assumption is that you've gone for the scene as a whole/'street' scene, in which case I think it's all nicely balanced. The crowd are to the side not blocking the figures in the painting or the guide, and the guide is also not blocking the figures in the painting. The crowd also makes a good frame around the guide without becoming too prominent overall. If you're trying for something more artistic then you'll probably need to try a more interesting angle as this doesn't offer much scope in that regards, and like you say it is a little flat. E.g. You could make it as if the viewer is looking over the shoulder of the person in front with the guide more prominent, but still partially blocked, and the painting looming over both.
-
@Zwuzelmaus@feddit.org 2026-05-02 09:33
Just because you wanted it :) I can't help *not* feeling inside the crowd / the scene, but behind the crowd. I can't decide if I should watch the white haired man or the painting. I don't know either... it is somewhat meaningless...
-
@SpaceXplorer_8042@lemmy.zip 2026-05-02 13:41
It looks to me like the subject is the person facing the camera as well as the art behind him. In that case and considering your intent to have the viewer stay among the audience, I think it looks good, although the painting could have had a little more headroom, or perhaps at a less steep angle.