Elektrine lite

← Feed

@NathanHarvey@kolektiva.social

2025-05-10 03:55 UTC

@highergeometer @TobyBartels @sibrosan I think one of the reasons I don’t like the mockery is that it ultimately tends to build environments where it is easy to attack people for things they don’t believe. It’s absurdifying. And I don’t think you’re intentionally lying about Wildberger, but I think you are able to uncritically believe these absurdifications, that you haven’t verified them yourself but they fit the environment of mockery and so make sense to you. I think anyone who actually has listened to Wildberger knows he accepts rationals despite them having infinite decimals. In fact, even though I pointed out in a previous message that the concerns he expresses are not in the fact of something having infinite decimals but in infinite process to bring to experience - despite that, you reasserted the characterization that he just doesn’t like any number to have that representation. Here he is talking about this with a lot of clarity: https://youtu.be/tXhtYsljEvY?si=LnOypQruybr0nrV9 He is actually very precise in his language, and follows classical, constructivist, and his own particular kind of finitist thought to analyze infinite decimals. In part 2, he reiterates the reasoning why infinite decimals are not used to define constructive reals by going through the 999 theorem. If you are earnest in wanting to judge Wildberger’s position, I really suggest this series of videos in his RNoLMF playlist, as I think he shows a clear understanding that mathematical objects have different representations and is explicitly pointing, time and time again, to the idealization that infinite processes are brought to completion in our experience. You will also note that he does not skew characterizations to strawman other ideas, or talk of “they”, or generally show the paranoid critical behaviors of those often described as cranks. He does have an uncommon foundational philosophy, but I think there are a lot of cool uncommon philosophies and I hate playing a popularity game. I just look at this whole thread. Dude found a new way to factor that’s kind of clever. The press coverage seems to rely on some pretty wild press release, which although maybe unseemly in mathematical circles is not uncommon among people who get a supplemental income from YouTube (and maybe not so uncommon in math history either?). I think it’s perfectly valid topic of moral discussion whether that was healthy or harmful characterization. I just don’t like to see negative sentiment slip to stereotype and nonsensification.

Replies (0)

No replies.